Persuasive Essay: Military Drafts
December 18, 2008Persuasive essay written for english 11 class:
The Country First
September 11, 2001, the day we will never forget. The tragic events of that day, most notably the destruction of the World Trade Center brought the concept of terrorism to a whole new level. Never again, would the United States of America tolerate such another attack. In less than a month, the United States had spearheaded an attack centered towards Afghanistan to “drain the swamp they [the terrorists] live in.” (Donald Rumsfeld). Within less than two years, the U.S. would find motives for the mobilization of even more troops; this time targeting Iraq. The purpose was an ambitious one: to liberate the Iraqi people from the tyrannical clutches of its government, and to neutralize any weapons of mass destruction that Saddam Hussein was presumed to have. Yet, how prepared was our military for such a task? Even before the events of 9/11, over 100,000 troops were spread across 130 countries. With the arrival of a new threat however, the U.S. military has suffered serious strains in its attempts to secure a foothold in the war on terror. Due to its shortage of manpower –especially in the regions of Iraq and Afghanistan– a draft is clearly needed in order to relieve the faltering military and defend the American public.
Signs of a stressed military struggling to accomplish its tasks have been emerging ever since the Iraq War. Earlier this year, the Foreign Policy magazine carried out an extensive interview on 3400 military personnel of high rank –both active and retired. In one particular survey, 88% of them agreed that “The war in Iraq has stretched the U.S. military dangerously thin.” Another survey question revealed that 60% believed that the military was considerably weaker than what it had been 5 years ago. An additional 80% agreed that the U.S. would not successfully be able to handle more military operations should they arise. Finally, an interesting scale given asking the health of certain branches of the army, with 10 being extremely concerned, the interviewed “reported an average score of 7.9 for the Army and 7.0 for the Marine Corps.” Therefore, a sizable draft is necessary in order for America to respond to another external crisis.
While these surveys all focus around external operations, it also brings to surface an important question: can the current military even defend its own homeland in the case of a possible attack? Earlier this year, the current Defense Secretary Robert Gates tackled this very problem after a “400-page independent commission report” claimed the U.S. was clearly not able to defend its country from an outside attack. His conclusion stated the “Pentagon must use the nation’s citizen soldiers to create an operational force that would be fully trained, equipped and ready to defend the nation.” Of course, with so many soldiers abroad, a military draft would be convenient in filling these domestic forces.
However, the manpower limits of the U.S. army currently add pressures to soldiers serving abroad as well. According to the Associated Press the U.S. Army Chief of Staff General George Casey has stated, “that the Army is under strain [in Iraq] from years of war-fighting and must reduce the length of combat tours as soon as possible.” Unfortunately, that is a prospect that will be hard to meet. As early as 2004, the military had been making serious attempts to keep troops an additional three years in Iraq despite the fact that their terms of enlistment had expired. Furthermore, of the 1.7 million troops that have served in Iraq, 600,000 (more than one-third) have been sent more than once. For many of these 600,000 troops, the heavy demand for soldiers has further decreased the time interval between one deployment to the next. Consequently, it is not surprising that the desertion rates have risen over 80% since the start of the Iraq War. “Desertions and unexcused absences have increased,” says General Casey, “You’re seeing folks not showing up for deployments.” “It’s a combination of not enough dwell time, and having to go back [to war]…” says Lawrence Korb, a former Pentagon official. Many may argue that a even with a military draft, desertions will take place. However, with a sizable military draft will come more soldiers to alternate between and replace other troops, decreasing the stress of soldiers and ultimately leading fewer soldiers to desert.
US military’s current ambition to become the aggressor by sending troops abroad in order to fight terror and spread democracy has drawbacks both abroad and domestic which requires more than what the regular army may be able to handle. To help relieve the pressures a draft would be the best answer to sustaining its tasks. Due to the magnitude of the threat that all Americans face, young men should be willing to sacrifice a little time in order to help defend America and its freedoms. While defending our nation is important, the effort in attacking abroad is equally important because it allows troops to disrupt many of the terror activities, which would otherwise be left alone to develop and eventually strike more destruction.
Bibliography:
“The U.S. Military Inex.” Foreign Policy. 2008. 16 Dec. 2008 <http://www.foreignpolicy.com/story/cms.php?story_id=4198&page=0>.
“Global Deployments of US Forces.” Global Security. 16 Dec. 2008 <http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/ops/global-deployments.htm>.
Montero, David. “More troops for Iraq and Afghanistan, Defense Department says.” Christian Science Monitor. 26 Feb. 2008. 16 Dec. 2008 <http://www.csmonitor.com/2008/0227/p99s04-duts.html>.
“US Army desertion rates rise 80 percent since 2003 Iraq invasion; highest rate since 1980.” International Herald Tribuen. 16 Nov. 2007. 16 Dec. 2008 <http://www.iht.com/articles/ap/2007/11/17/america/na-gen-us-military-deserters.php>.
Barnicle, Jeremy, and Leif W. Haase. “Legions Stretched Thin: The U.S. Army’s Manpower Crisis.” Century Foundation. 1 Oct. 2008. 16 Dec. 2008 <http://www.tcf.org/list.asp?type=pb&pubid=490>.
“US army battles to keep soldiers.” BBC News. 6 Jan. 2004. 16 Dec. 2008 <http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/3371225.stm>.
Baldor, Lolita C. “Gates: Review military’s role in homeland defense.” My Way. 25 Nov. 2008. 16 Dec. 2008 <http://apnews.myway.com//article/20081125/d94lpcd80.html>.
McMichael, William H. “Desertions highest since 2001.” Army Times. 18 Nov. 2007. 17 Dec. 2008 <http://www.armytimes.com/news/2007/11/military_desertions_071115w/>.
Posted by kchaiyoungl10




